Are Software Developers Real Engineers?

Are Software Engineers Real Engineers?

In the realm of engineering, professionals from various disciplines come together to create, innovate, and push the boundaries of design. Among these experts are traditional engineers, who build structures like bridges and buildings and software engineers who are developing groundbreaking solutions in the tech sector. Though both professions share the title of ‘engineer’ their roles, skills, and challenges vary greatly, or do they? For this blog, I’ve delved into the fascinating world of engineering to be able to provide you with a comparison and contrast of the key similarities and differences between traditional engineers—such as civil, and mechanical engineers—and their software engineering counterparts to decide once and for all what makes a “real” engineer.

To get to the bottom of this ongoing debate, we’ll explore the common ground they share and the unique aspects that set them apart in today’s fast-paced technology landscape.

We’ll first start by comparing their roles.

Let’s break down the roles of a Software Engineer and a Real Engineer

Let’s break down the roles of a Software Engineer and a Real Engineer.

Software EngineerDevelops software solutions, codes, tests and maintains systems to meet client needs.
Real EngineerConstructs physical structures or systems using scientific principles.

At first blush, it’s clear that both engineer types need mathematical and logical thinking, but for different applications. Each requires a separate set of skills to manage the challenges and responsibilities to complete their tasks.

At this 3,000-foot view, it seems there are more differences than similarities, so let’s break it down further and start with the traditional Engineer.

Pro Tip:

Celebrate both Engineers for their unique abilities and skills instead of comparing them. A real engineer can fix anything with just duct tape and WD-40!


Accelerate Your Engineering Team’s Growth

Characteristics of a Real Engineer

I think we can all agree that to truly possess the characteristics of a real engineer, you need to meet certain criteria. That’s why, in order to determine whether software engineers are real engineers, we need to discuss the key factors that define an engineer. These factors include education and certification requirements, the application of scientific principles, and ethical responsibilities. Let’s examine each of these elements in further detail.

Education and Certification Requirements

Engineers have distinct traits that set them apart from other professionals. This includes obtaining a bachelor’s degree in engineering, gaining licensure as a professional engineer, and ongoing education.

To become an engineer, one must do thorough coursework in math, physics, chemistry, and computer science. These studies give engineers the skills to design, produce, and evaluate complex systems. Plus, being licensed as a professional engineer means following state guidelines and high standards.

Engineers need to stay current with new advancements in their fields. Self-study or training may be needed for specialized certifications. By doing this, they are able to provide the best solutions.

Pro Tip:

Engineers who are hardworking and good problem-solvers usually succeed in this field. Real engineers not only use scientific principles, they conquer them.

Application of Scientific Principles

Real engineers possess analytical skills and use scientific knowledge to tackle complex challenges. They identify problems by utilizing empirical evidence, come up with questions, and create reliable solutions.

Their approach is systematic and based on facts, not assumptions. What sets them apart is their capacity to see things through a scientific viewpoint, enabling them to develop unique concepts outside the norm. Armed with their science foundation, they can analyze how materials could work together and predict the impact of different elements.

These engineers merge creativity with science to craft innovative solutions for next-gen sectors. The complexity of the projects requires more than technical knowledge; it calls for intellectual expertise. With the rapid development of technology, aspiring engineers must stay informed on modern trends to stay ahead.

It’s not only about building bridges but also being ethical with colleagues.

Ethical Responsibilities

Engineers must abide by moral and professional obligations to keep society safe, well, and private. They have to practice ethical behavior with their clients, peers, and environment. Adhering to these commitments is key in engineering projects.

Additionally, engineers must consider the effects of their systems on the environment. They are responsible for managing waste disposal and minimizing the environmental impact of a project over its lifecycle. With this, they support sustainable development objectives.

It’s significant for engineers to be aware of ethics codes related to their field and recognize government regulations concerning engineering operations. Furthermore, they should be answerable when things go wrong and take steps to stop similar issues from occurring in future projects.

As reported by Forbes, engineers who act ethically establish trust with stakeholders and forge better relationships with clients. This improves user satisfaction, the reputation of the firm involved in the project, and can open up new business opportunities.

So now that we have a shared vision of what a “real” engineer is, let’s flip the coin over and see how software engineers stack up.

Do Software Engineers Meet the Criteria of a Real Engineer?

To understand if software engineers meet the criteria to be considered as “real engineers,” the education and certification requirements, application of scientific principles, and ethical responsibilities of software engineers must be examined. These sub-sections offer a glimpse into the various facets of software engineering that contribute to the debate of whether or not software engineers are on par with traditional engineers in terms of knowledge and expertise in their field.

Education and Certification Requirements for Software Engineers

Software engineers need specific qualifications, certifications, and skills to be a pro. These include a bachelor’s degree in comp sci or a related field. Plus, certifications like CSDP and CSTP are valuable too. Certain roles may require specialized certifications, like CISSP for security-related roles.

To be successful, software engineers also need ‘soft skills’ like problem-solving, communication, teamwork, etc.

Application of Scientific Principles by Software Engineers

Software engineers are responsible for applying scientific principles, like math and logic, to design, develop, and maintain software products. They research, find the best practices, and document their processes. Plus, they must abide by industry standards such as ISO/IEC 12207 and IEEE Standards.

Testing is a key component of software engineering, where engineers use unit tests, integration tests, and performance tests to make sure their programs meet user requirements. Plus, software engineers need strong analytical skills and the ability to solve complex problems with math.  As some people will say it’s easy to be a software engineer, but hard to be a responsible one, let’s turn our focus to the ethical responsibilities of software engineers.

Ethical Responsibilities of Software Engineers

Software engineers must follow a set of ethical standards. They have to ensure the products are secure and safe for consumers, protect user privacy, and avoid any discriminatory practices. They must also not create programs that would enable harmful behavior or violate human rights. Transparency and accountability in their work is a must! It is essential to understand and respect cultural differences when building technology.

Confidentiality must be maintained when handling sensitive information. Data must be secured at every stage of development and deployment life cycle. Training on security measures is also essential. Product safety over any other factor must be prioritized when building applications. No part of the program should exploit users without their knowledge or consent.

Software engineers must consider any ethical implications throughout the application lifecycle. Professional organizations such as IEEE and ACM have set up principles that need to be followed. Engineers must re-evaluate these commitments, update them as technologies evolve, and make sure they stay relevant in an increasingly connected world. Software engineering builds bridges between humans and technology.

The Importance of Recognizing Software Engineering as a Legitimate Engineering Field

So now that you have read my well-crafted arguments, are you ready to acknowledge software engineering as a legitimate field? I assume it will be a resounding, Absolutely! In fact, it’s clear that software engineers are crucial in today’s world. Software engineers solve complex issues, design top-notch applications, and construct advanced systems.

Just like traditional engineers, software engineers use scientific rules and systematic methods to create, maintain, evaluate, and deploy software in multiple industries. They provide algorithmic solutions to enhance efficiency, plus interface designs for ease of use and to decrease human errors in dangerous environments.

Tech organizations have long recognized the importance of software engineering for their success. Without skilled software engineering, startups can suffer from low productivity and are at great risk of adding to the failure rate statistics.

Just as a side note, if you are looking for help to build a high-performing team of software engineers,  one company that has done particularly well in this area is TurnKey Labs, a staff augmentation company from Silicon Valley that offers excellent tech staffing services.

TurnKey’s model specifically stands out with its unique processes that ensure quality hires through a meticulous selection process for developers and software engineers. TurnKey doesn’t merely provide staffing solutions but also establishes dedicated software development team for your needs.

But I digress, not recognizing software engineering as a real field might cause a shortage of competent experts who can meet industry needs such as security engineering or AI integration, or open up niche areas such as audio processing using AI models.

It’s essential for organizations and institutions to support the acknowledgment of software engineering as an independent and organizationally beneficial area of study. Although software engineers may not build bridges or design engines, they do construct and design society’s technological infrastructure – so yes, they are real engineers.

Conclusion: Software Engineers are Real Engineers, too.

Software Engineering is a discipline that involves designing, developing, and testing computer programs. It’s closely related to coding and programming languages, making some people question if it qualifies as true engineering. But, software engineers fulfill all the criteria that define what an engineer is.

Their skills are used to solve complex issues through mathematical theory and innovative techniques. The focus is on developing reliable systems that perform the intended functions within budget and time restrictions.

One unique part of software engineering is the importance placed on teamwork. It’s essential for delivering high-quality results with maximum impact. Therefore, successful software engineers need to have good communication skills. This is necessary when working on cross-functional teams with people who may not understand technology.

The best software engineers stay up-to-date with programming language developments and network with other professionals. This provides insight into best practices that can enhance problem-solving abilities.

In conclusion, software engineers are real engineers just like mechanical or civil engineers. They possess proficiency in mathematics and science, use innovation-oriented problem-solving techniques, have exceptional communication skills, and experience working in cross-functional teams.

May 1, 2023

TurnKey Staffing provides information for general guidance only and does not offer legal, tax, or accounting advice. We encourage you to consult with professional advisors before making any decision or taking any action that may affect your business or legal rights.

Tailor made solutions built around your needs

Get handpicked, hyper talented developers that are always a perfect fit.

Let’s talk
🤖 Need more answers?

Please rate this article to help our team improve our content.

This website uses cookies for analytics, personalization, and advertising. By clicking ‘Accept’, you consent to our use of cookies as described in the cookies clause (Art. 5) of our Privacy Policy. You can manage your cookie preferences or withdraw your consent at any time. To learn more, please visit our Privacy Policy.